New York vs Indiana: Rent Comparison 2026
Side-by-side comparison of fair market rents, income, and tenant protections between New York and Indiana.
Indiana is 43% cheaper for a 2-bedroom rental than New York, saving renters approximately $662/mo ($7,944/year).
| Metric | New York | Indiana |
|---|---|---|
| Average 1BR Rent | $1,267/mo | $699/mo |
| Average 2BR Rent | $1,553/mo | $891/mo |
| Median Income | $86,864 | $54,260 |
| Renter % | 52.0% | 36.1% |
| Tenant Rights | 9/10 | 3/10 |
Rent Burden Comparison
New York
2BR Rent: $1,553/mo of $86,864/yr income
21.5% of income
Indiana
2BR Rent: $891/mo of $54,260/yr income
19.7% of income
Frequently Asked Questions
Is New York or Indiana cheaper to rent in?
Indiana has lower average rents. A 2-bedroom averages $891/mo, which is $662 less per month than New York (43% cheaper).
Which state has better tenant protections, New York or Indiana?
New York has stronger tenant rights with a score of 9/10 compared to 3/10.
What is the income difference between New York and Indiana?
New York median income: $86,864. Indiana median income: $54,260. Difference: $32,604/year.